Pipe Supports: Keep Piping System Secure and Steady

II JAY SHRI KRISHNA II

Piping systems, are elaborate networks of pipes, valves and fittings that facilitate the flow of fluids or gases. These systems can be quite heavy and they expand or contract with temperature changes. To keep them stable and prevent damage, we use external supports called 'Pipe Supports'.

Pipe Supports: Keep Piping System Secure and Steady

Pipe supports are external attachments that provide necessary restraint to counteract forces such as weight, thermal expansion and pressure. These supports are installed at various points along the piping system to provide stability and control movement.

This post will explain the basic functions of pipe supports, categorize them based on their design and purpose, and describe some common types of pipe supports. let's begin...!!

Pipe Supports: Keep Piping System Secure and Steady

Purpose of Pipe Supports:

The primary role of pipe supports is to:

Provide Stability: Supports prevent excessive movement and vibration of the piping system, ensuring its stability and preventing damage to connected equipment.

Control Thermal Expansion: As the temperature of the fluid within the pipes changes, the pipes expand or contract. Supports are designed to accommodate this thermal expansion and prevent excessive stress on the piping and its components.

Resist Gravity Loads: Pipe supports counterbalance the weight of the pipes, fittings and fluids, ensuring that the system remains securely in place.

Withstand Seismic Loads: In regions likely to earthquakes, supports must be designed to withstand seismic forces and prevent damage to the piping system.

Maintain Piping Alignment: Proper support alignment is essential to ensure accurate flow and prevent operational issues.

Pipe supports are critical components of piping systems, serving multiple purposes:

1. Weight Support:

Operational and Testing Loads: Supports must accommodate the weight of the pipe, fittings, and fluid under both operational and testing conditions. For vapor lines, hydrostatic testing can significantly increase the weight due to the added water. Supports must be designed to accommodate this increased load.

Load Distribution: For large-diameter pipes or high loads, additional supports may be required to distribute the weight evenly and prevent excessive stress.

Pipe Support System for Weight Distribution

Testing Considerations: While thermal expansion doesn't directly impact weight, it's crucial to ensure that supports can accommodate the additional stresses caused by thermal expansion and contraction. Spring supports are often locked during testing to prevent excessive movement and ensure accurate pressure readings. However, this can also impact the load distribution on the supports.

2. Thermal Expansion Accommodation:

Restricted Expansion: When a pipe's thermal expansion is constrained by a rigid support, it can lead to significant stress buildup in the pipe and the support itself.

Stress Relief: To prevent excessive stress and potential failure, supports should be designed to accommodate the expected thermal movement.

Flexible Supports: Spring hangers and other flexible support mechanisms are commonly used to allow for thermal expansion and contraction without inducing significant stress.

For example, The long, straight pipe which is fully restrained at both ends. As the temperature increases, the pipe will try to expand, but the fixed ends will resist this movement, leading to significant stress. A flexible support, like a spring hanger, can alleviate this stress by allowing the pipe to move freely.

In some cases, expansion joints can be used to accommodate large amounts of thermal expansion. These devices are specifically designed to absorb the movement and prevent stress buildup in the piping system.

3. Wind Load Resistance:

Wind can exert significant lateral forces on pipes, especially large-diameter ones. This can result in excessive deflection, vibration and potential damage to the piping system.

Key Considerations:

Support Design: Supports must be designed to resist these lateral forces and prevent excessive deflection or vibration. This often involves using rigid supports or bracing to reinforce the piping system.

Tall Supports: For tall supports, wind loads can induce significant bending moments. To mitigate this, engineers may need to use stronger materials, increase the support size, or add additional bracing.

4. Seismic Load Resistance:

Earthquakes can generate significant horizontal and vertical forces on piping systems. These forces can cause excessive movement, stress, and potential damage to the piping and its components.

Key Considerations:

Dynamic Forces: Seismic forces are dynamic in nature, meaning they vary with time. This makes it challenging to predict the exact loads that a piping system may experience during an earthquake.

Support Design: Supports must be designed to withstand these dynamic forces and prevent excessive movement. This often involves using special seismic restraints, such as snubbers or restrainers, to limit the displacement of the piping system.

Seismic Restraints: In high-seismic regions, additional restraints may be required to limit pipe movement during earthquakes. These restraints can be passive devices, such as snubbers, or active devices, such as seismic dampers.

5. Vibration Control:

Vibration in piping systems can be caused by various factors, including:

Pumps and Compressors: The operation of these machines can induce vibrations into the piping system.

Turbulent Flow: High-velocity fluid flow can cause the pipe to vibrate, especially in long, unsupported spans.

Key Considerations:

Support Design: Supports can help reduce vibration transmission by:

Isolating the Pipe: Using vibration isolators, such as spring hangers or elastomeric supports, can decouple the pipe from the vibrating equipment.

Damping Vibrations: Applying damping materials, like vibration dampers or acoustic insulation, can dissipate vibrational energy.

Span Length: The span length between supports can significantly impact vibration levels. Shorter spans tend to be less susceptible to vibration.

Pipe Material and Thickness: The material and thickness of the pipe can also influence its vibrational behavior.

For example, A long, unsupported pipe carrying high-pressure steam from a turbine to a condenser may experience significant vibration due to turbulent flow. To mitigate this, engineers can install intermediate supports or use vibration isolators to reduce the span length and dampen the vibrations.

By carefully considering these factors and implementing appropriate support design strategies, engineers can effectively control vibration in piping systems and ensure their long-term reliability.

6. Noise Reduction:

Noise in piping systems can be caused by various factors, including:

Vibration: Vibrations induced by equipment, fluid flow, or external sources can radiate noise.

Pulsating Flow: Pulsating flow, often caused by pumps or compressors, can generate noise.

Key Considerations:

Vibration Isolation

Support Design: Using vibration-isolating supports, such as spring hangers or elastomeric supports, can reduce the transmission of vibration to the piping system.

Damping Materials: Applying damping materials, like acoustic insulation or vibration-damping coatings, can absorb vibrational energy and reduce noise.

Silencers: Silencers are devices designed to reduce noise generated by turbulent flow or pressure fluctuations. They are often used in exhaust systems, ventilation systems, and other applications where noise is a concern.

Acoustic Enclosures: In severe noise cases, acoustic enclosures can be used to isolate the noisy equipment or piping section. These enclosures are typically constructed of sound-absorbing materials and can significantly reduce noise levels.

By implementing these noise reduction strategies, engineers can create quieter and more comfortable working environments.

7. Hydraulic Thrust Accommodation:

Hydraulic thrust is a force generated by the pressure differential across a component, such as a valve or fitting. This force can be significant, especially in high-pressure systems, and can cause pipe movement, stress, and potential damage.

Key Considerations:

Support Design: Supports must be designed to resist the hydraulic thrust forces and prevent pipe movement. This often involves using rigid supports or anchor points to restrain the pipe.

Stress Analysis: Engineers must perform stress analysis to determine the magnitude of the hydraulic thrust and its impact on the piping system. This analysis helps identify critical locations where additional support may be required.

Hydraulic Thrust Mitigation in Pipeline Design

For example, consider a large-diameter pipeline with a pressure reducing valve. The pressure drop across the valve can generate a significant hydraulic thrust force. To counteract this force, the valve can be anchored to the structure, and the piping system can be provided with additional supports to prevent excessive movement and stress.

8. Transient and Standby Conditions:

During startup and shutdown, piping systems experience transient thermal conditions, where different parts of the system heat up or cool down at different rates. This can lead to uneven thermal expansion, causing additional stresses and loads on the supports.

Key Considerations:

Uneven Thermal Expansion: Different components of the piping system, such as valves, pumps, and heat exchangers, may have different thermal expansion rates. This can result in differential expansion and contraction, leading to additional loads on supports.

Support Design: Supports should be designed to accommodate these transient thermal loads. This may involve using flexible supports, such as spring hangers, or providing additional restraints to limit excessive movement.

For example, consider a steam piping system with a long, straight section. During startup, the steam temperature increases gradually, causing the pipe to expand. However, if one end of the pipe is restrained, the expansion will be restricted, leading to stress buildup. To mitigate this, flexible supports can be installed to allow for thermal expansion and contraction.

9. Maintenance Conditions:

Maintenance activities, such as valve replacement or equipment removal, can significantly alter the load distribution and stress levels in a piping system. This can necessitate temporary support or adjustments to the existing support system.

Key Considerations:

Temporary Support: When a component is removed, the remaining piping may require additional support to prevent excessive movement or stress. Temporary supports, such as pipe saddles or hangers, can be used to provide the necessary support.

Stress Analysis: It's important to perform a stress analysis to assess the impact of the maintenance activity on the piping system. This analysis can help identify critical areas where additional support may be required.

Safety Considerations: Maintenance activities should be carried out safely, and appropriate precautions should be taken to prevent accidents and injuries. This includes ensuring that the piping system is properly supported and that workers are not exposed to hazardous conditions.

By carefully planning and executing maintenance activities, and by providing adequate support, engineers can minimize the risk of damage to the piping system and ensure the safety of personnel.

10. Shutdown Conditions:

During shutdown, the operating conditions of the piping system change significantly. This can lead to changes in the weight and thermal expansion of the pipe, which can impact the loading on the supports.

Key Considerations:

Weight Reduction: When fluid is drained from a pipe, its weight decreases. This can cause spring-loaded supports, designed to counteract the weight of the full pipe, to exert an excessive upward force, potentially overloading connected equipment.

Limit Stops: Limit stops are mechanical devices that restrict the upward movement of spring-loaded supports. They prevent the pipe from moving beyond a certain point, protecting the connected equipment from excessive loads.

Design Considerations: When designing support systems, it's important to consider the potential impact of shutdown conditions. This may involve selecting appropriate spring rates, incorporating limit stops, or providing additional support during shutdown.

11. Erection Conditions:

During the construction and erection of a piping system, it may be subjected to loads that differ significantly from those experienced during normal operation. These loads can include:

Temporary Loads: The weight of construction equipment, workers, and materials can impose additional loads on the piping system.

Misalignment: Improper alignment of components can induce stress concentrations and non-uniform load distribution.

Welding Stresses: Welding operations can induce thermal stresses and residual stresses in the piping system.

Key Considerations:

Support Design: Supports should be designed to accommodate the temporary loads and stresses associated with construction and erection. This may involve using temporary supports or reinforcing existing supports.

Inspection and Adjustment: After the installation is complete, the piping system should be inspected to ensure that all supports are properly installed and functioning as intended. Any necessary adjustments, changes or modifications can be made at this time.

Stress Analysis: A stress analysis can be performed to assess the impact of construction loads on the piping system and identify any potential issues.

Conclusion:

So, Pipe supports are very important. They hold pipes steady and prevent them from moving or breaking. This keeps the whole piping system safe. They prevent damage from weight, temperature changes, and other forces. By understanding their purpose and design, engineers can ensure the reliable operation of piping systems.

Kindly, follow my blogs on

Stress Analysis Basic Concepts and Terminology

Site Selection for a Plant: Key Considerations

Piping Supports: Key to Stronger Piping and Safer Operations

ASME B31.3: Codes for Piping Stress

Classification of Pipe Supports

Common Support Details Generally Used in Piping

Key Considerations for Secondary Support Design

Optimal Piping Support Design: For Pumps, Vessels and Exchangers

Pipe Support Design: Considerations for Different Piping Systems

Common, Basic and Important Interview Questions on Pipe Supports

Understanding Codes and Standards for Piping Materials