Checklist for Civil & Structural Considerations in Piping Engineering Drawings

II JAY SHRI KRISHNA II

In piping engineering, accuracy and collaboration are paramount. While the mechanical integrity and functionality of piping systems are often the primary focus, an equally critical dimension lies in their interaction with civil and structural components. These aspects ensure the safe installation, long-term stability, and maintainability of piping systems within industrial facilities.

Checklist: Civil & Structural in Piping Layouts

This post serves as a continuation of our previously published articles: “Checklist for Piping and Instrumentation Engineering Drawings Review” and “Piping Design Checklist for Accurate Engineering Drawings.” In this article, we present a Comprehensive Checklist for Civil & Structural in Piping Layouts—a crucial resource for engineering teams striving for seamless multidisciplinary coordination.

Checklist for Civil & Structural in Piping Layouts

Whether you’re in the design or review phase, this checklist will guide you in validating load data, plot plan alignments, support provisions, vendor coordination and much more—ensuring that all critical interfaces between piping and civil/structural disciplines are addressed. This attention to detail mitigates potential construction clashes, delays and safety risks.

_______________________________________________________

1. Information Issued to Civil Department

For a structural and civil engineering team to effectively support the piping system, they must receive accurate and timely information. This includes load data, special component details and layout revisions. The key points to confirm are:

✅Pipe Support Loadings: Ensure that restraint loads from anchors, guides and hangers are calculated and submitted.

✅Insert Plates: Indicate insert plate positions and specifications for embedding in concrete structures where supports will be mounted.

✅ Vendor Data: Cross-check all special piping components (e.g., spring hangers, dampers, expansion joints) and share structural implications.

✅Foundation Needs: Convey specific foundation requirements for large or rotating equipment such as pumps, blowers or compressors.

✅Revised Plot Plans: Verify that civil receives the most up-to-date plot plans aligning with piping routing and equipment locations.

_______________________________________________________

2. Confirmation for Loading Design Data

2.1 Loading Points

Different loads act on piping systems, and these loads transfer to structural elements. Each type of load must be identified, quantified and communicated effectively:

✅Anchor Points: Clearly mark locations where piping imposes significant restraint loads.

✅Instrument & Electrical Support Loads: Account for any trays, ducts, or control panels mounted on or adjacent to the piping system.

✅Wind and Seismic Loads: Evaluate site-specific conditions and communicate resulting lateral or dynamic loads on pipe racks and structures.

✅Maintenance Loads: Identify areas where heavy equipment or personnel may temporarily impose loads (e.g., for pump maintenance or valve replacement).

✅Girder Loading: If piping supports are mounted directly onto structural girders, specify load magnitudes and exact positions.

2.2 Direction of Loading

✅Thermal Expansion Reactions: Indicate both the magnitude and vector direction of loads caused by thermal expansion or contraction.

✅ Startup and Shutdown Loads: Consider alternate load cases from temperature transients or differential movements during commissioning or shutdown.

2.3 Types of Loading

A. Long-Term Loading

These long-term loads must be included in the structural design:

✅Thermal Reaction Forces: Often the largest sustained load acting on piping supports.

✅ Dead Loads:

Bare pipe weight

Insulation weight

Operating fluid weight (water, chemicals, etc.)

✅Thrust Forces: Especially from pressure surges or restrained expansion joints.

✅ Duct and Tray Loads: Loads from cable trays or instrument ducts mounted on pipe supports or racks.

B. Short-Term Loading

These short-duration loads can still critically impact structural integrity:

✅Pressure Test Loads: These often exceed normal operating pressures and must be evaluated for support capacity.

✅ Maintenance Loads: Load from lifting equipment, access platforms, or replacement components.

✅Wind and Seismic Loads: Dynamic loads based on geographical seismic zones and wind speeds.

✅Startup Conditions: Consider temperature profiles and thermal gradients during startup phases.

✅Friction Forces: Consider lateral loads due to pipe movement at sliding supports.

_______________________________________________________

3. Confirmation for Maintenance and Operational Accessibility

The plant's design must ensure decades of dependable operation with minimal disruptions. Structural and piping systems must therefore account for clearances, accessibility and safety:

3.1 Maintenance Considerations

✅ Overhead Clearance: Ensure no clashes occur above pumps, valves or accessways that restrict removal or inspection.

✅Pump & Equipment Maintenance Space: Verify adequate horizontal and vertical space for lifting or skidding equipment during major overhauls.

✅ Maintenance Lifting Requirements: Design civil structures with lifting beams, monorails or embedded supports for heavy equipment handling.

3.2 Operational Considerations

✅Patrol and Walkways: Design adequate and safe routes for operators to inspect and operate valves, gauges and other components.

✅ Structural Connections: Ensure loads from pipe bridges or support systems transferring into adjacent buildings are properly integrated.

✅Access Elements: Define appropriate spacing and positioning of stairs, ladders and platforms in multi-level structures.

_______________________________________________________

4. Piping Design Inputs for Civil/Structural Coordination

In addition to loads, several design attributes of piping systems directly influence the structural and civil design:

✅Document Revisions: Confirm all reference drawings (e.g., structural GAs, concrete layouts) are of the latest issue.

✅Expansion Joint Location: Clearly indicate to help determine flexibility, anchor positions, and support spacing.

✅Bracing Limitations: If there are no-go zones for bracing due to equipment or access, specify these areas.

✅Beam Depth Restrictions: Ensure compatibility between proposed piping support methods and available structural clearance.

✅ Pipe Rack Design:

Layer heights (typically top-down: utility, process, instrument air etc.)

Girder and support member spacing

✅Underground Interferences: Identify clashes with foundations, electrical conduits, drains or underground piping.

✅Thermal Movement & Insulation: Account for piping thermal growth and insulation thickness in clash reviews.

✅Large Bore or High-Temperature Pipe Location: Strategically place these closer to main supports to avoid excessive spans or loads.

✅ Structural Integration: Consider combining pipe rack columns with nearby structures for efficiency and cost savings.

✅Heat Exchanger/Drum Support Elevation: Determine how elevation will be adjusted (via pedestal, saddle extension, etc.) and share with civil team.

✅Steel Member Orientation: Confirm alignment of I-beams or channels relative to the direction of applied forces.

✅ Penetration Openings: Mark any required holes or slots in beams or slabs for piping passage.

✅Hold Points: Clearly flag pending issues or data required from civil/structural teams on the drawings.

_______________________________________________________

Conclusion:

The interface between piping and civil/structural engineering is complex but critically important. Misalignment at this junction often leads to costly rework, unsafe installations or future maintenance challenges.

This Comprehensive Checklist for Civil & Structural Considerations in Piping Engineering Drawings is designed to help professionals:

Streamline multidisciplinary collaboration

Reduce project risks and errors

Improve plant safety, accessibility, and efficiency

By ensuring a thorough and structured review process, piping engineers can significantly contribute to successful project execution. Use this checklist during design reviews, interdepartmental meetings, and third-party audits to maintain the highest quality standards in your engineering deliverables.